Opinion articles provide independent perspectives on key community issues, separate from our newsroom reporting.

Letters to the Editor

Jobs were lost decades ago

FILE - Then-Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump gestures during a campaign state Nov. 1 at the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire in Eau Claire, Wis. In his victory speech, Trump called them America’s forgotten men and women, the workers from the coalfields of Appalachia to the hallowing manufacturing towns of the Rust Belt. They felt left behind by progress, laughed at by the elite, and so put their faith in the billionaire businessman with a sharp tongue and short temper.
FILE - Then-Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump gestures during a campaign state Nov. 1 at the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire in Eau Claire, Wis. In his victory speech, Trump called them America’s forgotten men and women, the workers from the coalfields of Appalachia to the hallowing manufacturing towns of the Rust Belt. They felt left behind by progress, laughed at by the elite, and so put their faith in the billionaire businessman with a sharp tongue and short temper. AP

Some have proposed the mantra of foregone manufacturing jobs as an impetus for change. The truth is: These jobs were traded away decades ago. By the time Bill Clinton got into office with NAFTA, which was passed with Republican votes and opposed by Democrats such as Dick Gephardt, the cast had already been set.

Of course, this is not the real reason for this sudden outpouring for change. For this, one would have to delve deeper. Nobody really expects a man known to hire illegals and fight the unions of Las Vegas to come to the rescue of the working man in the guise of offering livable incomes.

Perhaps it was Susan Faludi in her 1999 book titled “Stiffed” that comes nearest in describing the demise of the modern working man and this fascination for a return to the mores of the 1950s. Maybe the real culprit is a feeling of insignificance and the desire for recognition. This is the true catalyst why demagogues are chosen with their super-inflated egos, to compensate for the rest whose self-image has become chest-fallen and seemingly irretrievable.

In the quest to fulfill this void, scapegoats are needed as well as blinders. The real causalities in this backward devolution are other segments of society who have struggled to find a respectable place. A culture that encourages belittlement is not only anachronistic, but a downright lie. A real man silently goes his way toward the cross while lesser men sleep, complain and rationalize. Unfortunately, the old cliche is true: Real men don’t cry, and quite frankly that is mostly what is heard concerning those who resort to fifth-grade tactics in the attempt to mask their own inadequacies. A good job can help, but not from old crumbling brickyards accompanied by specters of the past.

Terry Spence

Bradenton

This story was originally published November 16, 2016 at 2:32 PM with the headline "Jobs were lost decades ago."

Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER