National

Hunter shoots ‘black bear,’ then realizes he made a mistake, Idaho officials say

A hunter shot the wrong animal in Idaho’s Panhandle region, wildlife officials said.
A hunter shot the wrong animal in Idaho’s Panhandle region, wildlife officials said. Daria via Unplash

A hunter believed he was shooting a black bear when he fired his gun at an animal in northern Idaho, officials said.

It turned out to be a federally protected grizzly bear.

The hunter killed the female grizzly May 9 in the Priest Lake drainage area of Idaho’s Panhandle, Idaho Fish and Game said in a May 12 news release.

Once he realized his mistake, he reported himself to the Citizens Against Poaching hotline, officials said.

Now the incident is under investigation.

Grizzly bears are found in the northernmost part of the panhandle and in northeastern Idaho, officials said.

They are protected at a state and federal level, making it illegal to “harm, harass, or kill grizzly bears, except in cases of self-defense or the defense of others.”

These bears have been listed as a threatened species by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service since 1975 in the lower 48 states.

How to tell a grizzly from a black bear?

Wildlife officials warn hunters to make sure they properly identify an animal before shooting it, and that means knowing the differences between a black bear and grizzly.

A grizzly bear can be spotted by its short, rounded ears, shoulder hump, long claws and dished (concave) face profile, wildlife officials said.

A black bear has tall ears, a straight face profile, no shoulder hump and shorter claws.

The sizing and coloring of a bear are not reliable ways to determine the difference between the two, wildlife officials said.

Bears vary in size at different ages and in different physical conditions, making it difficult to identify a bear based on size alone, officials said.

Both bears also vary in color. A black bear can be blonde, cinnamon or black, while a grizzly bear can have nearly black coloring.

Anyone with questions can contact the Panhandle Regional office at 208-769-1414.

Read Next
Read Next
Read Next

This story was originally published May 13, 2025 at 6:32 PM with the headline "Hunter shoots ‘black bear,’ then realizes he made a mistake, Idaho officials say."

Helena Wegner
McClatchy DC
Helena Wegner is a McClatchy National Real-Time Reporter covering the state of Washington and the western region. She’s a journalism graduate from Arizona State University’s Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication. She’s based in Phoenix.
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER