Four passengers died on Zaandam cruise ship; 148 aboard sick with flu-like symptoms
Despite passenger deaths, positive COVID-19 tests and a possible week-long quarantine off the coast of Panama, the cruise ship Zaandam plans to transfer hundreds to a sister ship with little more than a temperature scan to determine if they’re healthy or infected with the coronavirus.
Four passengers have died aboard the Zaandam as it awaits permission to transit the Panama Canal, and almost 150 people are sick with flu-like symptoms, according to a release from Seattle-based Holland America cruise line. It is owned by Miami-based Carnival Corp.
The captain announced the deaths to passengers and crew Friday afternoon, along with news that two passengers have tested positive for COVID-19. He also stated the company planned to evacuate hundreds of healthy passengers to a sister ship anchored nearby.
The Zaandam originally left Buenos Aires, Argentina, on March 7 with 1,243 passengers and 586 crew on board for a two-week cruise. It anchored off the coast of Panama Friday, awaiting permission to pass through the canal and potentially berth in Port Everglades. It was turned away from its original destination, Chile, on March 21.
But the Panamanian government told reporters the ship would not be allowed to pass through if anyone on board had a confirmed case of COVID-19.
“If there are confirmed cases of COVID-19, the ship has to go into quarantine,” the administrator of the Panama Canal Authority, Ricaurte Vásquez, told Telemetro Reporta. “If there are elements of contagion, the ship has to go into quarantine. That is not an alternative or an option.”
In response, HAL Spokesman Erik Elvejord said in a statement, “While the onward plan for both ships is still being finalized, we continue to work with the Panamanian authorities on approval to transit the Panama Canal for sailing to Fort Lauderdale, Florida.”
Friday afternoon, the Panama Canal Authority doubled down with a statement that no ship with a COVID-positive individual on board may cross the canal.
“All ships transiting the Panama Canal require personnel, including line handlers, boarding officers, and Panama Canal pilots, to board the ship throughout the transit in order to ensure a safe passage throughout the waterway. These protocols are in place to safeguard our customers and workforce,” the statement read.
Family members of passengers aboard were alarmed by the news of a potential quarantine off the coast of Panama. Lisa Marion, a Toronto-area woman whose parents are on the ship, called it “a nightmare.”
“I’m concerned that the longer they stay at sea, the more likely they are to catch COVID-19. And if they are bound to have it, I want them here in Canada where they will get appropriate care,” she said.
As of Friday, 148 of the 1,243 passengers and 586 crew onboard are experiencing flu-like symptoms, the company said. On Sunday, that number was 42.
“I wish the U.S. would offer additional help, quicker help,” said Anna Marie Carton, a passenger aboard the Zaandam from Louis Park, Minnesota. She and her fiance are anxious to head home to their children.
Earlier this week, Holland America Line sent a sister ship, the Rotterdam, to aid the Zaandam. The additional ship was originally meant to bring medical supplies, personnel and COVID-19 tests, but the company has since decided to transfer hundreds of passengers from the Zaandam to the Rotterdam in what it calls a “humanitarian mission.”
The company said it will only transfer healthy patients who show no symptoms, starting with people in interior cabins and those over the age of 70, but it won’t be testing the passengers it transfers, according to a company press release. This has alarmed crew members aboard the Rotterdam, who are terrified of importing the illness to a ship with more than 600 crew aboard.
“Is it humanitarian to do this to the Rotterdam crew, that is here to support their families? Has anyone paused to think what is Holland America Line going to tell their parents, children, when they get infected and eventually die? Are they not seeing the news?” said a crew member aboard the Rotterdam who asked for anonymity out of fear of retaliation. “Who cares!? After all is crew members who are sent to slaughter!!!!”
The crew member also provided the Miami Herald with a document circulated by the company to Rotterdam crew answering frequently asked questions about the transfer of passengers to their ship. Many of the questions focus on the possibility of bringing the coronavirus along with the passengers; the answers downplay the risk to crew members, noting that many of them recently took shore leave.
“The trip ashore actually posed a higher risk than what we are suggesting with the transfer of healthy guests from Zaandam to Rotterdam. Catching a flight is now considered a high-risk exposure while serving healthy guests in isolation without any physical contact is considered a very low risk operation,” the FAQ said.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has said cruise ships are a veritable petri dish for coronavirus spread.
The FAQ document also said that there is little risk because passengers have already been isolated for five to six days and people with COVID-19 usually show symptoms “in about three to five days,” which is incorrect. The CDC says infected people can show symptoms anytime between two and 14 days, and some people contract the disease without showing any symptoms at all.
One question on the document read: ”If we do get a COVID-19 case on board, won’t we have created now two ships with trouble?”
“We believe this is a very low probability,” the answer read. “We should be able to fully prevent anything from spreading throughout the vessel while moving back up North.”
That attitude is not shared by passengers on board the Zaandam, even those who feel fine and hope to secure a spot on the other ship.
“We all know those going over to the Rotterdam could have the virus and spread it there,” said Cliff Kolber, a 72-year-old Miramar man on board the ship with his wife, who was reached by phone.
The FAQ explains that guests will be transferred from ship to ship via a “secure corridor” that will be “super” sanitized ahead of time.
In answer to a question about whether ship has even personal protective equipment — such as masks and gloves — aboard, the crew document said, “team who need PPE for a particular job they are doing will be provided it to wear based on their individual risk.” The document states that crew serving food to guests will not be given PPE because “there will not be direct exposure to the guests.”
Another answer on the document said that if crew has to enter the cabin, they will be given protective gear.
The FAQ explains that only guests with no symptoms will be transferred over, but said they will not be tested beforehand because “testing well people is not advised by any health experts.” The company only plans to use test kits to confirm whether COVID-19 is on board and causing the illness. It does not specifically answer the question of whether tests will be available for crew.
An isolated crew member aboard the Zaandam, who wished to remain anonymous, said the ship’s doctor said they would not be tested for COVID-19, despite showing symptoms earlier in the week.
“We went from not having a worry in the world as medical had been conducting temperature checks on all guests, to complete lock down and isolation in a matter of hours,” the crew member wrote in a message. “It is concerning staying onboard for another two weeks as we have seen how quickly it spreads.”
Several questions on the FAQ clearly show that the Rotterdam crew’s anxiety is well known by superiors.
In answer to a question about what happens if someone isn’t comfortable servicing cabins with food or laundry, the FAQ said “nobody will be pushed to do something that doesn’t feel right to them.”
“Why do we need to do this?” is one of the first questions listed.
“There is no other place for us to take the guests and no other means to provide assistance to the Zaandam and our fellow team members on board. This is the only option, as the ports and airports in South America and Central America are closed to us,” the document reads.
Some family members said they wish the company had just canceled the cruise altogether like other lines did around the same time.
“My parents only went because it wasn’t canceled,” said Marion. “It was also one of those things where you think ‘I’ve saved up so long for this, and the governments are telling me its ok to travel, so I guess I’ll get on the boat’.”
This story was originally published March 27, 2020 at 1:17 PM with the headline "Four passengers died on Zaandam cruise ship; 148 aboard sick with flu-like symptoms."
