TALLAHASSEE — In a full-barreled appeal to the House Policy Council, the oil and gas industry persuaded lawmakers to vote, 17-6, along party lines Tuesday for a bill that opens state waters to exploration and taps into new revenues for the state’s ailing budget.
The council approved an amendment by Rep. Dean Cannon, R-Orlando, that would lift Florida’s ban on oil drilling in state waters and replace it with a plan to allow the governor and Florida Cabinet to seek bidders for exploration and drilling in the Gulf of Mexico between three and 10 miles offshore.
New revenues would come from a $1 million non-refundable application fee for every bidder and, according to an industry-hired economist, from as much as $1.6 billion in royalties and taxes if the wells produce oil.
“We’re giving the governor and Cabinet that chance to have that dialogue with no obligation whatsoever,” Cannon said. “But we are taking away the shackles that currently prohibit Florida from not only pursuing energy independence but economic development and security and environmental protection.”
Sign Up and Save
Get six months of free digital access to the Bradenton Herald
Although the measure has no Senate companion, both the governor and Senate leaders said there may be time to consider it.
Gov. Charlie Crist said he was still reviewing the proposal, but was “intrigued’’ by the potential to extract oil “in a way that is safe, in a way that is clean and in a way that generates a lot of revenue for the state of Florida.”
The Senate’s top budget chief, Sen. J.D. Alexander, said he supports the idea of opening the Gulf to oil exploration. He suggested that the proposal may remain alive because he believes lawmakers may be forced to go past the planned May 1 end of session, giving them time to consider it.
Sen. Mike Bennett, R-Bradenton, told the Bradenton Herald his position against more reliance on oil and other countries to supply it has not changed.
“The more holes we punch in the Earth, the longer we are putting off doing the right thing, which is investing in renewable energy,” Bennett said late Tuesday.
Bennett said he is not opposed to offshore drilling for reasons including environmental effects or the potential impact on tourism.
Instead, he said he’s concerned about a reliance on oil making the United States rely further on other countries.
“As long as we are dependent on foreign oil, we’re still going to have kids dying in the desert,” he said noting more effort should be made to explore renewable energy.
“We’re dependent upon other people for our destiny and we should be in charge of our destiny,” Bennett said.
Cannon said he filed the last-minute measure to begin “a mature, thoughtful conversation’’ about pursuing future oil and gas exploration. He emphasized there is no guarantee that oil rigs will be positioned off Florida’s coasts and said there is no intent to pursue oil production off Florida’s Atlantic coasts or around Key West.
Every Republican on the committee voted for the proposal, and the only Democrat to support it was Fort Lauderdale Rep. Yolly Roberson.
It was harshly criticized by environmentalists who called it hasty and short-sighted and by Democratic U.S. Sen. Bill Nelson, a long-time opponent of drilling off Florida’s coasts.
Nelson sent out messages to his Twitter followers saying, “I can’t believe some Florida lawmakers might actually be serious about allowing oil drilling within 10 miles offshore.”
Cannon’s lengthy pitch to the committee included a Power Point presentation and handouts with charts and photos, funded by a group named Florida Energy Associates, which refuses to identify its members.
Lewis Sessions, a Dallas-based lawyer who said he represents several independent West Texas oil companies that he also refused to name, told the committee that last year Texas earned $7 billion from taxes and fees on oil and gas leases and production.
Session noted that long-time development lawyer Frank Matthews helped draft the Cannon proposal bill.
Mason Dixon pollster Larry Harris said an April poll on behalf of Florida Energy Associates found that if the public can be convinced oil and gas drilling is environmentally safe, 88 percent support it.
Short of that, 59 percent of the public generally supports it, he said.
Orlando economist Hank Fishkind told lawmakers that 15-year-old federal estimates indicate there are about 3 billion gallons of oil off Florida’s coast.
If 150 million barrels were drilled each year, at a rate of $53 per barrel and 20 percent royalties, the state would earn $31 billion over 20 years, or $1.6 billion a year.
He also predicted that oil and gas production would produce 17,000 to 20,000 jobs.
The environmentalists said they were caught off guard by the last-minute emergence of the proposal and urged the council to reject it.
“Please do not allow people who are being compensated most generously to articulate on behalf of the oil industry talk to you about the environmental sensitivity of oil drilling three miles from our coast,” said Debbie Harrison of the World Wildlife Fund.
She said the state’s coastal tourism and marine industries contribute $587 billion to Florida’s economy each year, according to the Florida Oceans Council.