Hospitals, biz alliances and residents support Medicaid expansion - pols don't

Herald/Times Tallahassee BureauMarch 25, 2014 

TALLAHASSEE -- The debate that dominated last year's legislative session hasn't gone away.

Hospitals, powerful business alliances and grassroots advocacy groups still believe Florida should access the billions of federal dollars available for Medicaid expansion.

The difference between this year and last: Nobody wants to talk about it.

House Republicans, who blocked a similar move in 2013, say there is no point in having the contentious conversation again.

"The federal government has parameters that are too constrictive," said state Rep. Richard Corcoran, R-Land O'Lakes, of the guidelines for accepting the money. "Until the feds say they will give us flexibility, there is no reason to move forward."

But critics say election-year politics are at play.

Polls show some registered Republicans in Florida oppose Medicaid expansion. And in an election year, Republican lawmakers are particularly wary of supporting policies associated with Obamacare.

"Ideology is the only thing stopping House Republicans from moving forward on this issue," House Democratic Leader Perry Thurston said. "Not expanding health care is the wrong thing for Florida."

Last year, the Senate unanimously approved a bill to allow use of federal Medicaid expansion dollars to buy private insurance policies for poor Floridians.

But the bill went nowhere in the House, which instead approved a proposal to reject $51 billion in federal Medicaid funding.

This year, Republican state Sen. Rene Garcia, of Hialeah, has introduced a plan for

Medicaid expansion in the upper chamber (Senate Bill 710). Freshman state Rep. Amanda Murphy, D-New Port Richey, is carrying an identical bill in the House (House Bill 869).

Neither has been scheduled for a hearing.

It's not for lack of support from influential groups. The Florida Chamber of Commerce continues to support Medicaid expansion, so long as there are certain prerequisites meant to control costs and improve outcomes.

"We have not backed off our position," said David Christian, vice president of governmental affairs. "But since there is no discussion -- nothing has been teed up -- you won't see me in front of a podium saying, 'This is our position on Medicaid expansion.'"

Instead, the Chamber is focusing its lobbying efforts on proposals that would expand access to telemedicine and address the shortage of primary-care physicians.

The Safety Net Hospital Alliance of Florida has also shifted its attention to something more pressing: a federal waiver that would prevent Florida from losing existing "low income pool" money for health services to the poor and uninsured.

"We are subject to losing $1 billion in federal money in the next 45 days," President Tony Carvalho said. "That's money that's being used to support the system."

Carvalho said his organization still strongly supports Medicaid expansion.

"Obviously, it's an uphill battle right now," he said.

Groups such as the Florida League of Women Voters and Planned Parenthood are making noise in support of Medicaid expansion.

Leah Barber-Heinz of the patient advocacy group Florida CHAIN hasn't given up hope, either. Her group recently ramped up its campaign to organize supporters on the local level.

"We know it is an election year, and Republicans think supporting (Medicaid expansion) will hurt them," Barber-Heinz said. "But if they listened to their constituents, they would find out that this is something the people really want. More people are accessing the marketplace and realizing they won't get a subsidy."

But a recent Tarrance Group poll of registered voters in Republican-held state Senate districts found 57 percent of Republicans disapprove of Medicaid expansion. And conservative groups such as the Koch-brothers-funded Americans for Prosperity have continued to rail against the proposal.

Corcoran dismissed claims he and other Republican lawmakers are motivated by politics. "All we've ever cared about is creating quality healthcare outcomes for Floridians," he said.

Said state Rep. Carlos Trujillo, R-Miami: "The Democrats try to paint everything as politics. This is policy. Medicaid is a broken system that is rife with fraud and has poor health-care outcomes."

Garcia hasn't given up on his bill in the Senate. He said he was still pushing Health Policy Chairman Aaron Bean, R-Fernandina Beach, to give his proposal a hearing.

"I haven't spoken with one member of the Senate who doesn't support our plan," Garcia said. "If we could get it on the floor, we could pass it."

Bean said he hadn't ruled out the possibility, but that it isn't likely.

"The problem is that time is precious," Bean said. "It wouldn't make a lot of sense for us to spend time discussing something that isn't going anywhere in the House."

Senate Budget Chairman Joe Negron, who sponsored last year's Medicaid expansion proposal, believes the issue is a nonstarter.

"Sometimes in life there are intractable differences that can't be resolved," he said. "We have continued to discuss possibilities with our friends in the House, but we have two very different ideas about how to proceed."

He wasn't hopeful a consensus could be reached.

Bradenton Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service