Company sues Florida over new law banning government hiring of firms tied to Cuba

Miami HeraldJune 5, 2012 

The Coral Gables-based subsidiary of Odebrecht, the Brazilian engineering and construction conglomerate, sued the state Monday over a contentious new Florida law that bans governments from hiring companies with business ties to Cuba.

The lawsuit, filed in Miami federal court, contends that the law is unenforceable and unconstitutional because it sets foreign policy — a power that the courts have ruled belongs solely to the federal government.

The law would prohibit state and local government agencies from awarding contracts worth at least $1 million to Odebrecht Construction Inc. — among others — because a subsidiary of its parent company is upgrading the Cuban Port of Mariel.

Gov. Rick Scott caused an uproar last month when he signed the law in a ceremony at Miami’s Freedom Tower, only to issue a statement shortly afterward suggesting the law was unconstitutional. The governor later retreated from that stance, saying he backed the law and that his administration would defend it against a likely legal challenge.

A Scott spokesman declined to comment Monday because the governor’s office had not yet received a copy of the lawsuit.

Sen. Rene Garcia of Hialeah, one of two Miami-Dade Republicans to sponsor the legislation, which received near-unanimous support from state lawmakers, said the court should uphold the law.

“This is not about foreign policy,” he said after learning about the lawsuit from a Miami Herald reporter. “I see it as a states’ rights issue. We have a right to decide who we want to do business with.”

In its lawsuit, however, Odebrecht argues that federal laws “do not authorize states to enforce their own sanctions against Cuba.”

The company also notes that it complies with the U.S. embargo on Cuba and “is remote and distant from, and has no contact with,” COI Overseas Ltd., the company working on the Port of Mariel for Brazil-based parent company Odebrecht S.A. Neither the Cuban affiliate nor the parent company work in Florida, the lawsuit says.

Florida-based “Odebrecht USA does not engage, and never has engaged, in business operations in Cuba,” the company said in a statement Monday in which it lamented having to sue a state agency “with which we have worked so successfully in the past.”

Odebrecht sued Ananth Prasad, secretary of the Florida Department of Transportation. Though FDOT has not denied Odebrecht the ability to compete on any bids yet, the agency informed the company that it plans to enforce the new state law when it is scheduled to take effect July 1. Odebrecht intends to bid on approximately $3.3 billion in FDOT contracts this year, the lawsuit says.

Odebrecht is seeking a temporary injunction to forbid immediate enforcement of the law, said the company’s lawyer, Raoul Cantero, a former Florida Supreme Court justice who is now a partner with the Miami law firm White & Case.

“We think the statute is illegal on its face, regardless of anybody bidding on anything,” Cantero said.

As precedent, Cantero cited a 2000 U.S. Supreme Court ruling striking down a Massachusetts law restricting business with companies tied to Myanmar. He also referred to two local cases.

In 2000, a federal judge ruled against Miami-Dade County’s requirement that companies submit sworn statements saying they did not work in Cuba. In 2009, another federal judge overturned a 2008 Florida law requiring travel agencies specializing in trips to Cuba to pay increased fees and bonds.

The county attorney has opined that Miami-Dade should not enforce the state law because it conflicts with federal law, though some commissioners disagree.

The law’s supporters have said that the new Florida law, which also applies to companies that do business in Syria, tracks federal statutes that hold that Cuba and Syria are state sponsors of terrorism, along with Iran and Sudan.

Though it’s unclear which, or how many, companies across the state would be affected by the law, business interests, including the Florida Chamber of Commerce and the governments of Florida’s top two trading partners, Brazil and Canada, have warned that the law could have a chilling effect on investment in the state.

Odebrecht USA, which was established in 1990, has been involved in most of South Florida’s major construction projects, including the American Airlines Arena, the Adrienne Arsht Center for the Performing Arts and the North Terminal at Miami International Airport.

It has recently been negotiating with Miami-Dade aviation officials to build a proposed project known as Airport City, which would include two hotels, office and retail space on airport grounds, though the project has stalled because commissioners have balked at giving the firm more business.

In April, Broward County commissioners awarded a more-than $225 million contract to Odebrecht USA as part of a joint venture to expand the southern runway at Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport.

According to the lawsuit, Odebrecht USA had more than 200 employees and revenues of $214.5 million in 2011. Since 1990, the company has been awarded more than 60 projects, valued at $4.94 billion. Of those, 35 projects — amounting to $3.9 billion — were for state agencies and local governments.

Read more here: http://www.miamiherald.com/2012/06/04/v-fullstory/2832880/odebrecht-sues-florida-over-new.html#storylink=cpy

Bradenton Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service